Offensive?
The Phillies were off last night, giving me a chance to do what I have been wanting to do since the calendar turned to May -- compare this year's offensive output with last year's, up to this point in the season. It would come as no surprise to anyone that the Phillies offense is struggling right now. The Phillies have scored 174 runs -- good for 5th in the NL -- in 35 games (just shy of 5 a game), despite a .252 average (10th) and seemingly no power whatsoever. The team slugging percentage is .397 (11th); to put that in perspective, Pat Burrell's SLG right now is .406, and we all know how much he is struggling. But how do these numbers compare to last season?
Actually, these numbers are not too far behind last year's totals. Last season, as a team, the Phillies hit only .259 and slugged .422. The influx of players like Jim Thome and David Bell, along with the continued development of Pat Burrell and the emergence of rookie Marlon Byrd was supposed to increase offensive output, not maintain the status quo. But it seems to this point in the year that the players are struggling...almost each and every one of them. That obviously can't continue forever, which is a reason why the Philadelphia Inquirer ran an article this morning about how the Phillies offense is about to burst out. But how much can we expect them to improve, and should the slow starts be a cause for concern? Let's look, position by position.
1st Base
Jim Thome was the free-agent signing of the winter and was expected to boost the Phillies offense -- not to mention make people forget Travis "What's His Name?" Lee ever wore red pinstripes. But Thome is not hitting well, and until his two homers the other night, wasn't crushing the ball. Through 35 games, Thome is hitting .254. He has "only" 6 homers and 26 RBI. But through this point last season, Thome was hitting an ugly .210! And yes, he had 9 home runs and 29 RBI, but he wasn't hitting much else. His slugging percentage this season is only .008 lower than it was at this time last year, and his OBP is .034 higher, thanks to 24 walks already this year. So minus a small dip in his power numbers, he's hitting better than he did at this point last season -- and let's not forget he finished last year at .304 with 52 HR and 118 RBI.
In addition to putting up better numbers than he did to this time last season, Thome is also outpacing Travis Lee's 2002 numbers. His average is 29 points higher, his OBP 40 points, and his SLG more than 100 points higher. And despite his "lack of power", he is still doubling up Lee's output through May 10th of last season -- 6 HR to 3, 26 RBI to 13. So despite his struggles, Thome is still giving the Phillies a better output, and based on his early-season struggles last season, we can expect an explosion this summer.
Advantage: 2003, with improvement to come
2nd Base
Placido Polanco, in his first full season with the Phillies, is putting up numbers above and beyond what I expected. He is hitting .300, which isn't a shock. But his OBP is above .400, and his SLG is at .438. These numbers put his OPS 245 points higher than it was last season at this time. We probably can't expect him to continue to play up to the level he is playing at now, but he is also not a .597 OPS guy. Surprisingly, he is giving the Phillies about what Marlon Anderson was giving them last season. Anderson's BA was in the same ballpark (.294) and his OPS was only 22 points lower, at a surprisingly high (for him) .820. Anderson's OBP was more than 50 lower, but he made up a lot of that difference with a SLG average around .470.
Advantage: Even
Shortstop
Here, we are comparing Jimmy Rollins to Jimmy Rollins. Rollins had a poor season last year, with a BA in the .240 and an OBP in the low .300s. Yet, through May 10th (35 games) last season, he was hitting .317 and getting on base 37.5% of the time. He had already swiped 7 bases in 11 tries. And from there, his numbers went downhill. This season, he is at .282 and getting on base almost 35% of the time. His stolen base numbers are down (3 for 5), but his other numbers across the board are equivalent to this time last season -- and much better than his final numbers on the year. Last year, he took a tumble...this year, things are looking up.
Advantage: 2003
3rd Base
A debate that will go on in Philly for a few years: are we better off with the 3B we have, or should we have held on to Scott Rolen? Rolen's numbers last year, surprisingly, were in the same ballpark as David Bell's 2002 numbers. Bell had a 30 point advantage in BA at this time last season, while Rolen held a 60 point SLG edge. Their OBP were practically even. But in 2003, David Bell is struggling mightily. His average has fallen to .217, and his OPS is below .600. My hope lies in the fact that last season, Bell had an awful May, followed it up with a good June, struggled again in July, but finished in August and September very strong. Things have to go up, right?
Advantage: 2002
Left Field
Pat Burrell. A complete mystery to this point in the year. He struggled early on last season, as well, and Larry Anderson has made a few references to it during broadcasts this week -- that it was about this time last year that he turned things around. But at this point last season, he was hitting .267. This year: .211. Last season, his OBP was .362, and his slugging was an even .500. This year: .300 and .406. His raw stats look comparable -- he had 2 more homers and 1 more RBI at this point last year. He had 2 more walks, and 3 fewer strikeouts. The main difference that I can find is in his average; last season, he had 4 more hits in 13 fewer at-bats. Since his strikeout totals are fairly equal, I removed his Ks from his ABs, and worked out his BA for balls put into play (H/(AB-K)). That number this year is .304. Last season, it was over .390. And this makes sense, as every broadcast I watch, the broadcasters are saying something along the lines of "He's 0 for 3, but has been robbed twice". In my eyes, he's not following one of the main rules in baseball: "Hit it where they ain't." If he can start to do this again, the average -- as well as the power numbers -- will go up again.
Advantage: 2002
Center Field
Coming into the season, not a whole lot was expected of Marlon Byrd, and he wouldn't have to do a whole lot to make people forget Doug Glanville. Unfortunately, to this point in the season, he has done less than that. Last year at this time, Glanville was hitting .244 with a paltry .312 OBP. Sadly, Byrd -- around one DL stint -- is hitting only .167 with an OPS barely over .500. Throwing Ricky Ledee into the argument puts the 2003 numbers above Glanville's output of a year ago, but considering the Phillies were counting on Marlon Byrd to man CF on a daily basis, 2003 has been a disappointment so far.
Advantage: 2003, but only thanks to Ricky Ledee
Right Field
Much was made of Bobby Abreu's slow start last season, yet he finished at .308 with 20 home runs and 31 stolen bases. Much is being made again this year about Abreu's early struggles, so take another look at last year's final totals. Why? Because his numbers so far this year pretty much match last season's numbers to this point. His OBP is 40 points lower this season, but he has drawn 5 fewer walks. A little more patience at the plate, and a summer warm-up, will bring Abreu's numbers to the expected level.
Advantage: Even
Catcher
Last season at this time, Mike Lieberthal was still getting back in the swing of things after 2001's knee injury. In early May, he was hitting .255/.314/.373/.687 before heating up in the late summer months. This year...well, the heat remained through the winter. Lieberthal has the only hot bat in the Phillies lineup right now, hitting .337/.412/.529/.941. He has more homers and RBI than this time last year, and 35 games into the season, still has more walks than strikeouts. Don't expect these numbers to stay this high, but expect the final numbers to be better than last year's.
Advantage: 2003
-----
So what do I take from this? At 4 of 8 positions, the 2003 performance is better than the 2002 numbers at the same point of the season. At 2 other spots, they are about equal. Yet, most of baseball's "thinking heads" agree that the Phillies are still struggling and should break out at any time. Considering they are 4 games better than last year's record through 35, and only 3 1/2 games behind a Braves team firing on all cylinders, I'm still looking forward to an explosive summer at the Vet.