Good job...take a few days off
The Phillies roll into the All-Star break after a 5-2 road trip that saw them take 2 of 3 in Montreal and 3 of 4 in New York. The Phillies had a chance for the four-game sweep yesterday, but after jumping on Mets pitching all weekend to the tune of 21 runs and 42 hits in the first three games, the Phillies managed to convert 12 hits yesterday into just three runs. Despite their inability to get baserunners home yesterday, the Phillies still managed a ninth-inning, two-out rally -- sparked by Nick Punto -- to tie the game, only to lose it in the bottom of the inning. Still the effort was better than we saw in most of the games through June.
At the break, the Phillies find themselves with a 52-40 record, 8 1/2 games behind the still-scorching hot Braves, who took 3 of 4 from the Cubs in Chicago. This is only the third time that the Phillies have reached the break with at least 50 wins in the last 20 years:
| Year | Record | Place | GA/GB | End of year result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1993 | 57-32 | 1st | +5.0 | Lost in World Series |
| 2001 | 50-37 | 1st | +1.0 | 2nd place, 2 games back of Atlanta |
| 2003 | 52-40 | 2nd | -8.5 | ??? |
In the other two seasons in which they had 50+ wins at the break, the Phillies were leading the division at the time. Not so this season. Still they find themselves in a playoff spot, leading the Wild Card race by one game over the charging Diamondbacks.
The Phillies are playing .565 baseball, which translates to a final record of either 91-71 or 92-70, depending on how you round. I think at the beginning of this season, many of us would have accpeted a 91-win season and thought that such a season would win a weakened NL East. But the Braves have played as anything but weakened, making the task that much more difficult for the Phillies. The Braves (61-32) current .656 pace would put them at 106 wins on the season, a pace which -- if they can keep it up -- is more than deserving of the division title.
So while the Braves are playing above the level at which many experts and not-quite-experts had predicted -- not to mention probably a notch or two above their heads -- the Phillies, despite all their struggles, are about on par with preseason expectations. The All-Star break leads me to revisit the preseason questions the Inquirer had asked and I had answered back in February. So without any further ado...
1. What's the batting order going to look like?
In Spring Training, the lineup looked like this:
SS Rollins
2B Polanco
1B Thome
LF Burrell
RF Abreu
C Lieberthal
CF Byrd
3B Bell
Needless to say, that didn't last long. Rollins hit himself out of the leadoff spot, Burrell hit his way as low as 8 in the lineup, and Lieberthal rose to the cleanup spot. Due to ineffectiveness and injuries, Larry Bowa has rarely been able to trot out the same lineup two days in a row. I read recently (and of course now can't find my source) that the most used Phillies lineup this season had only been used six times. That's sad. At the break, the general makeup of the lineup is this:
CF Byrd
2B Polanco
1B Thome
C Lieberthal
RF Abreu
SS Rollins
LF Burrell
3B Bell
Lieberthal and Abreu switch back and forth depending on who is on the mound for the opposition. The recent injury to David Bell has forced Tyler Houston (who batted fifth on Saturday) and Tomas Perez to jump into the lineup. And Burrell's struggles have led Larry Bowa to pinch-hit/double switch for him late in ballgames in the last few weeks.
I wrote in February that Rollins in the leadoff hole would be the key to the lineup. His up-and-down times factored into the offense's inconsistancies. Polanco was tried there with no luck, and Abreu's resistance to the leadoff spot led to his struggles. Since Marlon Byrd was moved off to leadoff, it is no coincidence that the Phillies are 5-1, and the one loss came in Byrd's only hitless game at the top.
Back in Spring Training, Bowa said that he would probably have to tinker with his lineup quite a bit until things got settled...no one thought he would still be tinkering.
2. How is the rotation going to be set up?
Back in February, it looked like Millwood, Wolf, Padilla, Myers, and a questionable Duckworth. The season started with Roa in the five-spot, while Duckworth was on the DL. Since coming off the DL, Duckworth has re-assumed his spot, and has pitched as you would expect a #5 pitcher to pitch: good at times, awful at others.
Millwood has been almost all that we expected, rolling into the break at 10-6. He has the no-hitter under his belt, and has accepted a leadership position on the pitching staff. But he may not be the best pitcher on the staff; that distinction may fall to All-Star Randy Wolf. Wolf, who is 10-4 and on his way to Chicago, has been the best and most consistant for the Phillies this year. He avoided his annual April slump, and started the season well. He kept it up through May and June, and found himself with his first All-Star nod.
Padilla, at 8-8, has been everything a .500 record implies: consistantly inconsistant. He had a very good April, which culminated in a masterful shutout of the Braves at the end of the month. That was followed by a horrible six weeks in which he seemed to lose faith in any pitch that wasn't his fastball. But sometime in the last 3-4 weeks, he has re-found that confidence that led him to the All-Star game last season, and has evened his record.
The pleasant, if not unexpected, surprise has been the work of Brett Myers. Myers goes into the break at 9-6, just missing the chance to join Millwood and Wolf with 10 wins at the break. He managed to survive an April that saw him get virtually no support and a bad stretch in early June, and surround those with some gems. The highlight, of course, was his 3-hit shutout of the Red Sox in late June. Myers has shown the ability and willingness to learn, meaning the second half of the season and subsequent seasons should be even better.
3. What about the bullpen?
Here's what I said in February:
As the only area that was not significantly upgraded by Ed Wade this off-season, the bullpen is full of "if"s. If Jose Mesa can hold it together for one more year... If Terry Adams can remain comfortable in the set-up role after finishing last year so strong... If Turk Wendell can come back and pitch like he did for the Mets 3 years ago... If Carlos Silva can continue to grow and improve... If Dennis Eckersley of 1989 showed up in the 'pen...
What a shock they have been. Mesa has increased my Tums consumption, but the rest of the bullpen has been better than could ever be expected. Adams has remained strong, if not spectacular, in the setup role. Wendell has not only returned from injury, he has made the Phillies fans forget the tail end of 2001 -- 34 innings, 25 hits, 1.59 ERA. As good as he has been, Rheal Cormier has been even better. The guy I penned in as the odd-man-out at the end of Spring Training has thrown 47 1/3 innings, has a WHIP under 1.00, and an ERA of 1.52. Anyone who predicted that made a bunch of money off of Vegas. Dan Plesac has filled the specialist role nicely, and while Silva hasn't been as good as last season, the rest of the bullpen has pitched well enough that Silva has been hidden in the long relief/mop-up role. As a whole, the bullpen ranks 2nd in the NL.
If there has been any segment of the team that has overperformed this year, it has been the bullpen.
4. What's the plan for Bud Smith and David Coggin?
I'm not sure the Phillies even know anymore. Bud Smith was set to go under the knife...again...after he recently felt some pain in his throwing shoulder that Ed Wade deemed as -- paraphrasing here -- "more than a normal bump in the road". He is slated for surgery, and will be out for the season. Coggin...he has put in a few decent innings in Single-A Clearwater, but needless to say his recovery has taken longer than the Phillies had hoped.
5. Can the Phillies win the division?
In February, I said yes. But no one saw the 2003 Braves being as good if not better than the previous versions. With an 8 1/2 game deficit, the division has become tougher to win, although not yet impossible. A more likely goal is the Wild Card, but these races will flesh themselves out as the season winds down.
In spite of all of the offensive inconsistancies, the Phillies are about where everyone thought they would be. The offense isn't as good as advertised, but the pitching has been good, with the bullpen sometimes registering as "great" -- see the 16 innings of one-run ball in Baltimore for reference. The record is about where we thought it would be, although it has been a struggle to get there. If it were not for the Braves that will never die -- and even in spite of them -- the NL East race down the stretch could become a lot of fun.
